Monday, December 25, 2023

Die Hard

...is not a Christmas movie. Now that we've gotten that out of the way, we can commence discussing this legendary 1988 action flick. Set in five-hundred-foot skyscraper called the Nakatomi Plaza, terrorists take over...wait, wait. I can't simply leave it at that, can I? It's true that lots of folks genuinely (and passionately) argue about whether or not Die Hard, the action-packed thriller directed by John McTiernan based on the novel Nothing Lasts Forever by Roderick Thorp that reframed Bruce Willis into an iconic action star, is a Christmas movie. 

What arguments are made for the film being considered a Christmas one? I'm still don't totally sure. There's a few Christmas songs in there, and the characters mention the word Christmas about six or so times in the first twenty minutes (before the heist starts). But it seems to me that with that shaky reasoning, you might as well consider Goodfellas a Christmas movie. "Holly!" they shout. "His wife's name is Holly! Like the Christmas trees!" Not sure that would hold up in court.

If Christmas stories revolve around themes of love, family, generosity, and the spirit of giving, it's a bit of a stretch to say that the content of Die Hard relates to any of those. Christmas movies are to me about the redemptive and rebirth quality of the holiday season; at the very least, the protagonist learns some sort of lesson, one in which they are made better because of it. This is true of A Christmas Carol and How the Grinch Stole Christmas! and It's a Wonderful Life and A Christmas Story; it is also true of the newest Christmas classic: this year's wonderful film, The Holdovers. None of that exists in Die Hard. It is true that the first twenty minutes or so of the movie (again, before the actual heist starts) flirt with these notions. There is the estranged marriage of John McClane, a New York cop played by Willis, and his wife (Bonnie Bedelia); a quarrel between the two at a Christmas party held by her employer, Joseph Yoshinobu Takagi (James Shigeta), the head of Nakatomi, takes places just before the action starts.

Once the film really becomes the Die Hard we know and love—the jump from the building, the cat-and-mouse games, "yippie-ki-yay, mother fucker" and all that—it more or less stops tip-toeing its way to holiday themes. McClane kills one of the thieves and taunts the others with a cryptic message ("Now I have a machine gun—ho ho ho"), he uses Christmas tape to hide a gun on his body, and the film concludes with "Let It Snow! Let It Snow! Let It Snow" I'm still not totally sold on these scenes qualifying the movie as a holiday film.

Thanks to the debate over this, some concerns of Die Hard tend to be glossed over or forgotten, like the film being sort of peak-cop worship and its almost excessive violence, not to mention its arbitrary, gazy (yet brief) nudity. Lots of the film is praiseworthy, though, particularly the exceptional talent of McTiernan and his team for creating such a tense, fun action flick. And Willis is especially worthy of praise as McClane, the bare-footed, cigarette-chomping, muscular rogue cop molded like a cowboy who is also vulnerable and often on death's door but usually one step ahead of the bad guys. Willis' charm and energy on the screen is incredible, and it's impossible to envision any other actor in the role. 

Could someone other than Willis have found their way into the film? It nearly came to be that way. It may come as a surprise to many (including me), but Die Hard is technically a sequel (in the way that The Silence of the Lambs is technically a sequel to Manhunter). Thorp had written a novel called The Detective in 1966, which was released as a motion picture two years later by 20th Century Fox with Frank Sinatra in the lead role as Joe Leland (the protagonist's name in both The Detective and Nothing Lasts Forever). The studio was contractually obligated to offer the role in its adaptation of Nothing Lasts Forever to Sinatra, who felt he was too old at the time. The role (eventually changed to John McClane) was then offered to just about every major Hollywood star at the time one would think of for a project like this: Clint Eastwood, Sylvester Stallone, Harrison Ford, Richard Gere, Mel Gibson, Arnold Schwarzenegger, Al Pacino, and others. A major chance was then taken with the hiring of Bruce Willis, who at that point was known more as a comedic actor in television, and he had only been in six previous films. 

The filmmakers found quite an equal for Willis to play the villain Hans Gruber: Alan Rickman, who made his film debut here after about a decade of theatrical work. I would guess that Ricman's German accent isn't the most accurate in the world, but what he delivers as Gruber has become renowned for being an exceptional movie villain.  Hans Gruber is on virtually every list of the best movie villains of all time, including Collider's, Business Insider's, Empire's, the AFI's, Watch Mojo's, and USA Today's. "I'm going to count to three," he warns Mr. Takagi after he and his group of thieves have stormed the plaza and demanded the code for the vault. "There will not be a four." These are some cinema's most chilling threats. As John and Hans participate in this cat-and-mouse game in the skyscraper, they take turns with who has the advantage over the other. John rings the fire alarm, and the criminals override it. He calls the police, and the criminals impersonate security guards and convince the officer that everything is fine. The variety of thrills felt during these scenes (the loud ones and the quiet ones) are terrifically augmented by Michael Kamen's almost operatic score. 

Willis and Rickman lead a mostly competent cast, with a whole host of characters showing up along the way: There's Reginald VelJohnson in a very VelJohnson role as Sergeant Al Powell (a role he would reprise in Die Hard 2), a beat cop assigned to investigate the disturbance at the plaza, only to get roped into the mess and be basically the only man McClane can trust; Paul Gleason in a very Gleason role as the argumentative LAPD deputy chief who tussles with Powell and often makes the mess messier; and Robert Davi in a very, very Davi role as one of the FBI agents ("the other one," he deadpans into the radio because both FBI agents are named Johnson). Other effective performances include William Atherton as a reprobate TV reporter and Alexander Godunov as Gruber's menacing second-in-command. Two performances that are noticeably obnoxious, however, are Clarence Gilyard as the tech specialist in Gruber's crew (who literally chews up the scenery) and Hart Bochner as a sleazy Nakatomi exec who thinks he can schmooze his way out of trouble with the bad guys. Both performances are distracting.

Released in July (which I guess is Christmas season to some people), the film performed better than expected, ultimately becoming the seventh-highest grossing film of 1988. Who could blame audiences for being attracted to such a motion picture? In a year dominated by comedies (Coming to America, Big, Twins), Die Hard was able to fill the vacuum of lackluster action flicks like Rambo III with Sylvester Stallone and Red Heat with Arnold Schwarzenegger (Willis' co-stars in The Expendables) with a funnier brand of action. The blend of action, comedy, and drama in the initial script and rewrite by Jeb Stuart and Steven E. de Souza, respectively, mesh such genres in a way that few films have been able to do since, despite all the copycats. Notable instances of such combination include McClane and Gruber (disguising himself as a hostage named Bill Clay) finally coming face to face and McClane jumping from the building with only a firehose strapped around him while slowly being dragged towards the ledge.   

You know, in the course of writing this article, the more I think of it, the more I can tolerate it being considered a holiday film. The Nutcracker is an important tradition for many during the holiday season, and it too takes place during a Christmas party and features far fewer Christmas tropes than Die Hard does. If watching Die Hard during the Christmas season brings people happiness, then who am I to tell say they're wrong? One rationalization for considering it Christmas canon that does make sense to me (and one that is hardly ever mentioned) is the film's frequent use of Beethoven's Ninth Symphony, particularly when the final (4th) movement ("Ode to Joy") is beautifully played as Hans (Alan Rickman) and the other thieves finally break into the vault. Fans may or may not know that in Japan, for example, this music is considered an important Christmas tradition. This is perfectly fitting, given the film's setting at the Nakatomi Plaza. Christmas movie or not, Die Hard has stood the test of time all these years later and has spawned four sequels (with some being better than others). At this point, I'm a little exhausted of the odd debate over its status as a Christmas movie. Call it a Christmas film if you want or don't. I just hope you enjoy it as much as I do.  

Saturday, December 16, 2023

Stop Making Sense (and a List of My Favorite Talking Heads Songs)

There's a perfectly eccentric start to the concert, a concert that would be part of Talking Heads' final tour, with frontman David Byrne strolling onto the stage to the sound of adoring fans as he gently places a portable cassette tape on the ground. "Hi," he says. "I've got a tape I want to play," and then he begins strumming the famous opening notes of "Psycho Killer," the band's first hit, accompanied by a beat provided by the player (or, in reality, a Roland TR-808). This is the dawn of Stop Making Sense, the renowned concert film directed by Jonathan Demme of Talking Heads performances in 1983, which appeared a lot this past year as the film was remastered and the four members of Talking Heads reunited to promote it. The irregular opening should not be unexpected, but it is just as pleasant as one can imagine, as equally pleasing as it is to see these four apparently on good terms again.

As exceptional as "Psycho Killer" is, and as awesome as the the funky, calmer rhythm heard here than the version on Talking Heads: 77, it may be controversial to point out that Byrne's voice is weak is certain moments of this opening. (He did, at one point, claim that he didn't feel he had a great singing voice, and his school choir teacher rejected him for the choir for being off key.) Regardless, it's an unbeatable start, and you would be challenged to avoid bobbing your head along with him. Fortunately, there is not a bad song included for the remaining part of the show. The big ones are there, too—"Burning Down the House" and "Once in a Lifetime" being obvious examples—and whatever issues there are with Byrnes' singing voice, his writing skills more than make up for them, as he is the writer or co-writer of almost all of the songs featured in the concert. 

One by one, Byrne is joined by other musicians. First, bassist Tina Weymouth joins him to sing "Heaven" in perfect harmony. Then, Chris Frantz and his energetic drumming show up for "Thank You For Sending Me an Angel." Next, Jerry Harrison comes out for "Found a Job." Once the four members are finally assembled, they are eventually joined by backing singers Lynn Mabry and Edna Holt, guitarist Alex Weir, keyboardist Bernie Worrell, and percussionist Steve Scales. The viewers, whether in the actual concerts or viewing at home or in the cinema, will all witness the large amount of fun everyone is having on stage; it is evident that all the performers are having a blast. Indeed, it seems like it was all a great cardio workout, as they're moving about and running in place so much that they're drenched in sweat by the end. It's a miracle none of them (particularly Byrne) collapsed halfway through the show. 

There are other highlights worth praising, as well, chief among them Byrne's eccentricities, which are hard not to pleasantly smirk at. Another high point is when he takes a break, allowing Weymouth and Frantz to take the stage as their side project, Tom Tom Club, and their hit 1981 song "Genius of Love." This show is dripping with euphoria, despite what came after for the group. Talking Heads split up in 1991, about eight years after these filmed concerts. Weymouth recently discussed the pain of some of the band members' fights, saying, "Families do that. They don't just bite each other. They take chunks out. The beauty of it is, well maybe you don't forget, but you forgive." If there were tensions or fighting behind the scenes at the time of this tour, though, there is no evidence of it on stage.

One cannot discuss Stop Making Sense without mentioning one of the most joyous moments of the documentary: the big suit. This is the image of the film, the Kabuki-inspired suit that swings about as Byrne prances around the stage in an absurdist style to "Girlfriend Is Better" (which is where the lyrics "stop making sense" come from) that has likely lasted the longest and, one could argue, helped make it such a cultural success. Stop Making Sense was a undoubtable hit upon its release, with critics like Pauline Kael calling it "close to perfection." Future Oscar-winner Demme would go on to do two more concert films, with the other two featuring Neil Young and Justin Timberlake. The film was recently restored, remastered, and re-released by A24 this past September. This re-release marked the band's first reunion since they were inducted into the Rock and Roll Hall of Fame in 2002.

There are individual moments that I quite liked, which I've already mentioned. Holistically, it stayed with me less than I had hoped it would have. Concert films are among the kinds of films that provoke the least amount of interest in me, as I always prefer to simply listen to the music of the performers than watch a recording of their concert, and I've never been a concert-goer. (As a matter of fact, I think only the second concert film I ever saw was the 2020 Spike Lee-directed American Utopia of Byrne's Broadway concert.) Therefore, I can only say that I wasn't in love with Stop Making Sense as a film experience, just as I wasn't in love with American Utopia or BeyoncĂ©'s Homecoming or probably any other future concert film I will see. One complaint I have is that Demme didn't seem to add much or a personal voice to the project as Lee had with American Utopia

I don't mean to criticize this approach too much. Demme never had a specific consistent voice like Lee has had, and his camera helped capture so many different emotions and elements to the successful show. But the film is credited as a film by Jonathan Demme and Talking Heads, and yet the latter comes across as more of the auteurs in command. (Byrne even designed the stage lighting himself.) These complaints are a bit of nitpicking. Those who do adore concert films will likely love this one, as it is commonly regarded as one of the best, and it goes without saying that it is required viewing for fans of Talking Heads. It is also that good of a show that those who are unfamiliar with their music will likely enjoy the ride. 


The Best Talking Heads Songs
Note: I made this list in 2020. Some of the numbering would likely be different if I were to do it again today.

50. Big Daddy
49. Totally Nude
48. People Like Us
47. Dream Operator
46. No Compassion
45. Papa Legba
44. Moon Rocks
43. Paper
42. Mr. Jones
41. Girlfriend Is Better
40. Puzzlin' Evidence
39. Swamp
38. Television Man
37. The Girl Wants to Be with the Girls
36. Ruby Dear
35. Drugs
34. Two Note Swivel
33. Cities
32. Air
31. Radio Head
30. Found a Job
29. The Good Thing
28. The Great Curve
27. First Weak/Last Week...Comparison
26. Don't Worry About the Government
25. Making Flippy Floppy 
24. Blind
23. Heaven
22. Thank You For Sending Me an Angel
21. Happy Day
20. Tentative Decisions
19. Mind
18. Crosseyed and Painless
17. Slippery People
16. City of Dreams
15. New Feeling
14. Houses in Motion
13. Hey Now
12. Born Under Punches
11. I Zimbra
10. Burning Down the House
9. Uh-Oh, Love Comes to Town
8. (Nothing But) Flowers
7. Take Me to the River
6. This Must Be the Place (NaĂŻve Melody)
5. Wild Wild Life
4. And She Was
3. Psycho Killer
2. Once in a Lifetime
1. Road to Nowhere

Sunday, April 30, 2023

20 Years of Top Ten Lists

I suppose I was a sophomore in high school when I first jotted down what I thought were the best films I had seen that "Oscar season," among them movies like Chicago and About Schmidt. (I later cheated and added a few when I saw them a few years later—something I try to avoid—such as Monsoon Wedding and The Kid Stays in the Picture.) Film critics are more or less required to create these kinds of lists at the end of the year, although the level of enjoyment varies from critic to critic. Dan Kois at the New York Times wrote in 2011 that while he really has loved making top-ten lists at the end of the year ever since he wrote for his high school newspaper, he recognizes that for many critics, the lists are "artificial exercises, assertions of critical ego, capricious and necessarily imperfect." That same year, Emily Nussbaum at the New Yorker wasn't shy about saying that she hates making top-ten lists, writing that she felt her teeth grind as she made a list in that very same article.

Why do I keep making lists of my favorite films of the year? It's not like I'm getting paid to do it. Why would anyone enjoy making lists? Linda Weeks at NPR had a neat way of answering the question: "Lists," she said, "bring order to chaos." And off Robert Kraft's ten benefits of making lists, my favorite is the first: externalizing what we need to remember. I have a list for everything. I make to-do lists and grocery lists. I list my favorite fifty songs of different musicians I like, such as Beyoncé, Lady Gaga, Dolly Parton, the Beach Boys, Bruce Springsteen, Janelle Monáe, Willie Nelson, Aretha Franklin, the Notorious B.I.G., Stevie Wonder, Pink Floyd, and Paul Simon, among many others. I once even ranked the colleagues I disliked the most at a place I worked. But my favorite lists to make are top-ten movie lists.

Although I make lists to help me remember the films I've seen, I have forgotten much about a few movies that I once thought were best. These include 21 Grams, which Wikipedia tells me is a psychological drama from 2003 directed by Alejandro González Iñárritu starring Sean Penn and Naomi Watts; Millions, a 2004 British comedy-drama directed by Danny Boyle about a boy who speaks to imaginary saints and altruistically spends a bunch of money he's found; and Taxi to the Dark Side, a 2007 documentary directed by Alex Gibney about a taxi driver in Afghanistan who was tortured and beaten to death by U.S. soldiers. There are some I remember a few moments from (like the ring stopping in mid-air like a tennis ball in Match Point) and how they made me feel (a bit nauseous, from the same film), but if lists are in fact for helping to externalize what we need to remember, then I owe these films another visit. 

I've tried to make sure I don't go back and edit these lists once they're finalized. This relieves some pressure. By doing so, I avoid having to go back and contemplate shifting around a bunch of films I saw years ago. I also can only defend some of the selections by saying that they are a snapshot into who I was in the past. Of course I've changed. When I saw Crash as a freshman in university (after four years of going to a mostly white high school), I imagine I probably thought of it as a profoundly progressive and brutally honest depiction of racism. (I also figured that if the film was good enough to top Roger Ebert's top ten of that year, it would surely be good enough for me.) Yet progressive or not, well intentioned or not, and many years after all the backlash, I viewed it again when I watched all ninety Best Picture winners. It then really sunk in just how problematic the film was and is. Should I go back and change the list? What's the point? I barely have enough time to make a top-ten list each year; how could I possibly go back and continually edit previous years'? 

Other than Crash, I think a lot of my early picks demonstrate a bit of maturity for a young person who knew nothing about film. Sure, I may have been a lot more into Pirates of the Caribbean: The Curse of the Black Pearl twenty years ago than I am now, but that year's top pick was The Fog of War: Eleven Lessons from the Life of Robert S. McNama, which won the Oscar for Best Documentary and was shown to us by Mr. Brewer, my high school history teacher. Since then, and since I am not (except for a brief stint reviewing films for my college newspaper) a professional film critic who gets sent to see a whole bunch of films a week, I have usually used Rotten Tomatoes' annual list of top one hundred films to help me decide which films to try and make my way through throughout the year. (I usually see about sixty percent of those films.) It's for this reason that I don't get the, let's say, smug criticism some have levied towards the website. I recently saw and liked the film that made Rotten Tomatoes' top slot of last year: No Bears, directed by, written by, produced by, and starring Jafar Panahi, who was arrested last July and sentenced to six years in prison for "propaganda against the regime" of Iran. I also liked the movie directed by Panah Panahi, his son, called Hit the Road, a film that made Barack Obama's annual list. For whatever reason, I didn't like either enough to include them on my list from last year. 

Some of the years, I found many of the films to be wonderfully enticing, like 2013, which saw the release of films like American Hustle, Fruitvale Station, The Past, and 12 Years a Slave, which won Best Picture. Other years, like 2019 and 2022, I struggled (and failed) to find even ten films that really stayed with me. But all of the following films I (at least one point in time) really liked. Anyway, here is my list of my top-ten lists:

The Best Films of 2002

10. Insomnia
9. The Hours
8. Chicago
7. Catch Me If You Can
6. Adaptation
5. Road to Perdition
4. Harry Potter and the Chamber of Secrets
3. Bowling for Columbine
2. About Schmidt
1. Spirited Away

Honorable Mentions: One Hour Photo, Spider-Man, The Pianist, Red Dragon, My Big Fat Greek Wedding, The Kid Stays in the Picture, Gangs of New York, The Count of Monte Cristo, Punch-Drunk Love, Monsoon Wedding

The Best Films of 2003

10. Mystic River
9. Monster
8. Finding Nemo
7. The Lord of the Rings: Return of the King
6. X-2: X-Men United
5. Peter Pan
4. 21 Grams
3. Pirates of the Caribbean: The Curse of the Black Pearl
2. Whale Rider
1. The Fog of War: Eleven Lessons from the Life of Robert S. McNama 

Honorable Mentions: Seabiscuit, The Last Samurai, 28 Days Later, Shattered Glass

The Best Films of 2004

10. The Life Aquatic with Steve Zissou
9. Vera Drake
8. Million Dollar Baby
7. The Aviator
6. Fahrenheit 9/11
5. Harry Potter and the Prisoner of Azkaban
4. Team America: World Police
3. Collateral
2. Finding Neverland
1. The Passion of the Christ

Honorable Mentions: Hotel Rwanda, Lemony Snicket's A Series of Unfortunate Events, Shrek 2, Super Size Me, Shaun of the Dead, The Machinist, Meet the Fockers

The Best Films of 2005

10. Transamerica
9. Grizzly Man
8. Good Night, and Good Luck
7. The Three Burials of Melquidas Estrada
6. Brokeback Mountain
5. Syriana
4. Sin City
3. Mysterious Skin
2. Downfall
1. Crash

Honorable Mentions: The Squid and the Whale, Match Point, Capote, Walk the Line, Weather Man, Hustle and Flow, Millions, Body of War, Cinderella Man, Star Wars: Episode III—Revenge of the Sith, Batman Begins

The Best Films of 2006

10. The Last King of Scotland
9. The Queen
8. The Good Shepherd
7. Casino Royale
6. The Prestige
5. The Departed
4. Little Miss Sunshine
3. Children of Men
2. An Inconvenient Truth
1. Borat: Cultural Learnings of America for Make Benefit Glorious Nation of Kazakhstan 

Honorable Mentions: Akeelah and the Bee, The Pursuit of Happyness, World Trade Center, Little Children, The Fountain, Jesus Camp, V for Vendetta, Crossing the Line

The Best Films of 2007

10. Things We Lost in the Fire
9. Into the Wild
8. Enchanted
7. Zodiac
6. Sicko
5. American Gangster
4. Lars and the Real Girl
3. There Will Be Blood
2. No Country For Old Men
1. Hot Fuzz

Honorable Mentions: Stardust, Charlie Wilson's War, Black Snake Moan, Atonement, Taxi to the Dark Side

The Best Films of 2008

10. Be Like Others
9. Mamma Mia!
8. Boogie Man: The Lee Atwater Story
7. Gran Torino
6. Frost/Nixon
5. The Wrestler
4. Milk
3. Slumdog Millionaire
2. The Dark Knight
1. WALL-E

Honorable Mentions: Dear Zachary: A Letter to a Son About His Father

The Best Films of 2009

9. Let the Right One In
8. Food, Inc.
7. Departures
6. Up
5. Coraline
4. Watchmen
3. Paranormal Activity
2. World's Greatest Dad
1. Collapse

Honorable Mentions: Anvil! The Story of Anvil, The Lady and the Reaper, Zombieland, Star Trek

The Best Films of 2010

10. Exit Through the Gift Shop
9. Rabbit Hole
8. Best Worst Movie
7. Dogtooth
6. The King's Speech
5. Winter's Bone
4. Wo Ai Ni, Mommy
3. The Kids Are All Right
2. Mother

The Best Films of 2011

10. A Better Life
9. Hot Coffee
8. The Kid With a Bike
7. A Seperation
6. The Interrupters 
5. Horrible Bosses
4. Hugo
3. We Need to Talk About Kevin
2. The Tree of Life

Honorable Mentions: Beginners, 50/50, Rise of the Planet of the Apes

The Best Films of 2012

10. Looper
9. Argo
8. The Perks of Being a Wallflower
6. Django Unchained
5. Amour
4. The Woman in Black
3. Rust and Bone
2. Monsieur Lazhar
1. Moonrise Kingdom

Honorable Mentions: Life of Pi, The Grey, The Sessions, Skyfall

The Best Films of 2013

10. The Past
9. Nebraska
7. American Hustle
6. This Is the End
5. The Hunt
4. Fruitvale Station

Honorable Mentions: The Wolf of Wall Street, The Hunger Games: Catching Fire, Saving Mr. Banks, Mud, Europa Report, Blood Brother, The Angel's Share, August: Osage County

The Best Films of 2014

10. The Overnighters
9. Snowpiercer
8. In Bloom
6. The Rocket
4. Leviathan
3. The Babadook
2. Pride

The Best Films of 2015

9. I Am Big Bird: The Carol Spinney Story
8. Ex Machina
7. What We Do in the Shadows
6. Where to Invade Next
5. Trainwreck
4. Paddington
3. Brooklyn
2. Inside Out
1. Room

Honorable Mentions: The Hunting Ground, The Walk

The Best Films of 2016

10. Moana
9. Toni Erdmann
8. Florence Foster Jenkins
7. Eye in the Sky
6. Under the Shadow
5. Lion
4. Arrival
3. O.J.: Made in America
2. Kubo and the Two Strings

Honorable Mentions: Weiner, Captain Fantastic, Don't Breathe


10. Get Out
9. Battle of the Sexes
8. Three Billboards Outside Ebbing, Missouri
7. The Post
6. Coco
4. Kedi
3. The Big Sick
2. The Salesman
1. The Florida Project

Honorable Mentions: The Disaster Artist, The Lego Batman Movie, Thor: Ragnarok, It, Call Me By Your Name, Spider-Man: Homecoming, BPM (Beats Per Minute)

The Best Films of 2018

8. Widows
7. Mary Poppins Returns
6. Paddington 2
5. Roma
4. The Hate U Give
2. Hereditary
1. Won't You Be My Neighbor?

Honorable Mentions: First Reformed, Crazy Rich Asians

The Best Films of 2019

8. Marriage Story
7. The Lighthouse
6. Honeyland
5. Toy Story 4
4. The Farewell
3. Knives Out 
2. Rafiki
1. Little Women

The Best Films of 2020

10. On the Record
9. The Invisible Man
8. Host 
7. Minari
6. Boys State
5. Crip Camp
4. Saint Frances
2. His House

Honorable Mention: Disclosure 

The Best Films of 2021

10. Lead Me Home
9. Bo Burnham: Inside
8. Rita Moreno: Just a Girl Who Decided to Go For It
7. Old Henry
6. The Power of the Dog
3. Two of Us
2. Spider-Man: No Way Home
1. The Rescue

Honorable Mention: A Quiet Place Part II

The Best Films of 2022

7. Prey
6. Fire Island
5. The Duke
4. Beavis and Butt-Head Do the Universe
3. The Red Suitcase
2. Hustle
1. Official Competition 

Friday, April 28, 2023

Peter Pan and Wendy

 

"His eyes were the blue of the forget-me-not, and of profound melancholy, save when he was plunging his hook into you, at which time two red spots appeared in them and lit up horribly. In manner, something of the great seigneur still clung to him, so that he even ripped you up with an air, and I have been told he was a raconteur of repute. He was even more sinister than when he was polite..."

"To die would be an awfully big adventure."


Does anyone really want to grow up? For all the drivel that has been pounded into our brains over the past few years about the joys of aging, is there anyone who really would prefer the demands and pressures of adulthood to the joy and simplicity of childhood? James Hook certainly does not. For all his talk about how much he hates the proud, insolent youth that is his arch nemesis, he still moans about the cracking of his bones. Peter Pan may dread the thought of growing old, but Hook seems to embody the universal hatred of it. "This is what growing up looks like," Hook scowls to an encaged Wendy.

As for Peter, well, his hatred of adulthood and adults is well known. If you look at the eight reasons why people hate growing up according to Catherine Winter, Peter possesses at least seven of them: fear of autonomy and loneliness, less fun, not knowing any happy adults, vanity, unresolved childhood trauma, a feeling of being trapped in the glory days of youth, and perhaps a personality disorder such as being overdramatic or unpredictable. (He does at one point slam the door, which one of the Lost Boys says is never a good sign, meaning he must do it often.) The only one he surely does not have is the last one: "To grow up means that they're adults," Winter writes. "Once they're adults, they have to acknowledge that they're aging. Aging means growing old. Growing old means they're going to die. Although death is part of the natural life cycle for every living thing, death-denying Western culture cherishes youth and beauty, and vilifies old age. Death is something to be battled against, denied, ignored, not dealt with at all."

Come to think of it, perhaps Peter does fear death. He battles it quite literally against the only adult he is in somewhat regular contact with. Would dying really be an adventure, as Peter claims? That's probably just a defense mechanism to suggest that he's afraid of nothing. Indeed, he's afraid of everything. This Peter, played here by Alexander Molony in his debut performance, even cries and tells Wendy (played by Ever Anderson) that he ran away when his mother scolded him. Peter, the Lost Boys (and girls, as is the case here, which surely must be a first), and even Hook himself are all devoid of mothers. That's why they cling to Wendy so much. Given that so many characters here lack a mother, a mother figure, or really any kind of parent, and given how important the role of a mother can be in a child's developmental growth, it's no wonder so many of the characters turn out the way they do. The audience cheers for the boy Peter Pan against the grouchy authoritarian that is Captain Hook, but Peter Pan is really one of the most pro-adult tales there is.

Disney tries to show us this in their latest live-action remake of one of their older animated films, the 1953 animated Peter Pan, adapted here as Peter Pan and Wendy, which is at least the dozenth adaptation of J.M. Barrie's famous story about a boy who won't grow up and the vengeful pirate out to get him. Disney (ever so slightly) plays with such ideas of anxiety and the consequences of motherlessness, so Peter Pan and Wendy is not as two-dimensional as other adaptations, like the 1923 version (the first on-screen adaptation of the story), the Broadway version (whose rerun in the 1980s was perhaps the first time I had come in contact with this famous story), or the animated version that the film reminds us was inspired by (when in fact they share very little in common, tonally at least).   

When watching the first twenty minutes or so of this newest film, one might wonder if it will be just like all the other versions. Adapting this story is risky; be too faithful of an adaptation, and you could make the film stale, while trying something too novel could make the whole thing wobbly (such as it was in a sequel like Hook or a prequel like Pan). Indeed, the only noticeable deviations in the first act are minute ones: Tinker Bell is less adversarial towards Wendy than she is in other versions, and the children already know who Peter Pan is from their stories by the time he flies into their home. For a while, it's unfortunate that the film follows all the usual beats while checking all the boxes: the pirates, the crocodile, the shadow, crowing, the thimble being mistaken for a kiss, and all that stuff.  

Fortunately, however, the film is in good hands, and when director David Lowery (who also directed The Old Man & the GunThe Green Knight, and Disney's live-action remake of Pete's Dragon) nudges the story in different directions, the results are mostly good. The first example of this is when Peter, Wendy, George, and Michael fly out of the London skies, through Big Ben, and right into what seems to be another realm. This would be an appropriate time to praise the contributions of the others in this project, namely cinematographer Bojan Bazelli, whose choice of color palate adds an authentic fairy tale aesthetic, costumer designer Ngila Dickson, and Zoe Jirik and Jade Healey, whose set decoration and production design (respectively) are so much better than the excessive stand-in of green screens. 

Indeed, one of the only flaws of the 2003 Peter Pan (which is still probably the best of the adaptations) is its overuse of Industrial Light and Magic's computer-generated imagery, which sometimes gave that film a fake look during the height of Hollywood's obsession with CGI. Instead, the visual effects provided by Framestore and DNEG not only look better twenty years after 2003 Peter Pan, but they sometimes make up for the film's narrative flaws, meshing exceptionally well with the gorgeous scenery of the Bonavista Peninsula in Newfoundland. This may not be the very best version of Peter Pan, but it is certainly the best looking. 

The acting is also (mostly) good, especially the earnestness of the two leads and the tenderness of Molly Parker as Mrs. Darling. The actor who looks like is having the most fun is, as expected, Jude Law as Captain Hook. Every eyebrow he raises, every line he shouts, every threat he gives with his prodigious hook look like they are done with great theatricality and gratification. The cast in general is slightly more diverse, with Tinker Bell being played by Yara Shahidi, and the Lost Boys are a diverse group of boys and girls, many of whom are people of color. Noah Matthews Matofsky makes history as the first person with Down syndrome to appear in a Disney film; he plays one of the Lost Boys. Finally, Alyssa Wapanatâhk plays Tiger Lilly, who's a larger part than she was in the past, with her being just as much an action star as Amber Midthunder was in Prey last year. Wapanatâhk's casting is noteworthy because, despite the character being indigenous, she is often played by people of other ethnicities, like Anna May Wong in the 1923 version or Rooney Mara in Pan. The film's diversity is a strength, though one wishes film companies would go further and be brave with on-screen adaptations of Austin Chant's novel Peter Darling in which Peter is a trans man or Jodi Lynn Anderson's book Tiger Lilly, which is told through this character's perspective. However, given Disney's fight with Ron DeSantis and corporations' fear of being called "woke," this is unlikely to happen. Additionally, there has already been racist attacks at Disney for this slightly more diverse cast, with bigots whining about it (right on cue). This likely is a warm-up act for their vitriol against the upcoming The Little Mermaid.         

Is Peter Pan and Wendy the best version of this famous tale? Probably not. Is it the second best? Probably. Children will likely love the film, especially the flights, the fights, and even the humor, but they will also probably like any Peter Pan film. The adults will find themselves relating to Hook for reasons previously mentioned. As for me, the production designs were top-notch, and the actors all looked like they were having a ball. I like how the film toys with deeper themes; I just wish it had gone further. 

Sunday, March 12, 2023

All 54 2023 Oscar Nominees, Ranked

In terms of predicting the winners for the 95th Academy Awards, doing so this year is considerably more difficult than it was in recent years. There are genuine horse races in most of the acting nominations, with only comeback kid Ke Huy Quan in Everything Everywhere All at Once considered a lock for Supporting Actor. Outside of that race, the only other safe bets are "Naatu Naatu" from RRR winning Best Song, the German film All Quiet on the Western Front getting the win for International Feature Film, Avatar: The Way of Water winning for its beautiful visual effects, and Guillermo del Toro winning his third Oscar for his version of Pinocchio. Most other awards are anyone's guess, with several nominees in each category gaining momentum but not having it in the bag. 

So many questions will be answered tomorrow: Will the younger, hipper Everything Everywhere All at Once prevail, or will the older, more establishment-friendly The Fabelmans pull an upset? Will the Academy award the sharp theatricality of Martin McDonagh's The Banshees of Inisherin script or the popular absurdity of the Daniels' in Everything Everywhere All at Once? Will it be Top Gun: Maverick or All Quiet on the Western Front for Sound? Elvis or All Quiet on the Western Front for Cinematography? Babylon or (again) All Quiet on the Western Front for Production Design? Austin Butler or Brendan Fraser? Michelle Yeoh or Cate Blanchett? Jamie Lee Curtis or Angela Bassett or Kerry Condon? The only sure thing is that there will likely be no shocking moments at this year's ceremony like last year's...well, you know. 

I wish I could say something about how they're all good films, and I'd be perfectly happy with anyone of the winners, but alas, 2022 was not my favorite year for the movies. I have some thoughts. So, without further ado... 

54. Blonde
Actress in a Leading Role (Ana de Arnas)

Blonde, the adaptation of Joyce Carol Oates' novel about a fictionalized take on the life of Marilyn Monroe, is grotesquely aggressive and almost unbelievably full of itself. It's truly a struggle to make it through to the end of this film; it must have taken me a week to do so, and the only way I could achieve such a feat was by eventually breaking up the viewing into installments of about five or ten minutes a day. Ana de Arnas, the film's star, has made a career of fantastic performances, but her work here as Monroe is not one of them. Oscar nominations for acting are often called out for celebrating not necessarily best acting but "most acting," and De Arnas's acting here certainly qualifies as the latter, with an enormous amount of screaming and crying, rinsing and repeating. Even if one is a fan of her performance in this film, it's hard to see how any of the other actors are doing any good, especially Xavier Samuel as Cass Chaplin and Evan Williams as Eddy Robinson. No other movie on this list seems to be trying so hard to be so bad like Blonde does. 

53. Babylon
Costume Design (Mary Zophres), Original Score (Justin Hurwitz), Production Design (Florencia Martin, Anthony Carlino) 

Babylon has often been described as "divisive" (even it's director knows it is), but calling it that really begs the question: Who are the fifty percent of viewers who actually like such a film? A second-rate attempt to recreate what worked in Singin' in the Rain and a variety of other films that explored early Hollywood, there's not a single good performance in this film, and it must be said that this is the goofiest performance ever of Margot Robbie's career. Never before has a film so accurately summed itself up than in Babylon; in this case, it's Brad Pitt's Jack Conrad, who summarizes a film he's starring in as follows: "It's shit. Another giant swing toward mediocrity." Perhaps summing up Babylon that way would be too much of a compliment. 

52. Marcel the Shell with Shoes On
Animated Feature Film (Dean Fleischer Camp, Elisabeth Holm, Andrew Goldman, Caroline Kaplan, and Paul Mezey)

Now that I've got my complaints against Blonde and Babylon out of my system, I feel I've exhausted myself of complaining about some of these other films, but I will find at least some energy to complain about the overrated bore that is Marcel the Shell with Shoes On. Unlike with Blonde and Babylon, I am not plagued by the recency factor with Marcel the Shell with Shoes On in my lack of appreciation of this movie, a film about a talking shell being interviewed in a mockumentary. That does not mean I liked it a whole lot better. I was bored by Marcel the Shell with Shoes On almost as much as I was by Blonde and Babylon, and I really struggled to I can't understand why everybody (or anybody) liked this movie; I liked nothing about it.

51. Bardo, False Chronicles of a Handful of Truths
Cinematography (Darius Khondji)

A lot of films directed by Alejandro Iñárritu can be on the insufferable side, but Bardo, False Chronicles of a Handful of Truths takes the cake. "Self-indulgent and pretentious" is how the Wikipedia article on it describes the reaction to the film. With a title like Bardo, False Chronicles of a Handful of Truths, how can it not be? It pretends to care if its audience recognizes how apparently self-aware and absurdist it is. The plot is meaningless, there is little (if any) emotional appeal to the film, and it's just a film directed by Iñárritu in which he's finally being called out for going overboard. 

50. Puss in Boots: The Last Wish
Animated Feature Film (Joel Crawford and Mark Shift)

The good thing about this totally unnecessary sequel is that its animation style, inspired by Akira and Spider-Man: Into the Spider-Verse and at times tonally influenced by Spaghetti Westerns like The Good, the Bad and the Ugly and Once Upon a Time in the West, is unlike anything else we have seen in the Shrek franchise, especially the first Puss in Boots film in 2011, which at that point had begun to look flat and stale. The bad news is that this follow-up is overly morbid, and there's not one laugh in the entire thing. Antonio Banderas has always been charming as this character, but it's not enough to save the film, especially from the annoying voice acting of Harvey GuillĂ©n. One would think that after almost twenty years, certain jokes would get old, but don't tell that to Dreamworks. They may have a new animation style, but it is literally the same jokes they were doing in 2004.  

49. Tell It Like a Woman
Best Original Song ("Applause" by Diane Warren) 

Tell It Like a Woman is an American-Italian anthology film consisting of seven short stories directed by women. In addition to the United States and Italy, other entries included were filmed in India and Japan, and the cast includes actors like Marcia Gay Harden, Eva Longoria, and Jacqueline Fernandez. Unfortunately, it starts with a surprising misfire with a short directed by Taraji P. Henson and starring Jennifer Hudson in a really unimpressive, distracting performance. Fortunately, some of the films are at least a little better, most notably one featuring Ann Watanabe as a single mother of two young children and their daily routines in Japan. The incomparable Diane Warren received her fourteenth nomination for Best Original Song this year, and although she finally received an Honorary Oscar last year (an award she had "been waiting a long fucking time for"), she is unlikely to win yet again this year. If she didn't win for songs like "Nothing's Gonna Stop Us" and "I Don't Want to Miss a Thing," she's not going to win for a song like "Applause." 

48. Elvis
Actor in a Leading Role (Austin Butler), Cinematography (Mandy Walker), Costume Design (Catherine Martin), Film Editing (Matt Villa and Jonathan Redmond), Makeup and Hairstyling (Mark Coulier, Jason Baird, and Aldo Signoretti), Production Design (Catherine Martin, Karen Murphy, and Bev Dunn), Sound (David Lee, Wayne Pashley, Andy Nelson, and Michael Keller), Best Picture (Baz Luhrmann, Catherine Martin, Gail Berman, Patrick McCormack, and Schuyler Weiss)

I was hoping we were long past the era of dry biographical films of entertainment legends, but I was wrong. Elvis continues this tradition and doesn't care if you're bored by it or not. Tom Hanks as Tom Parker is very...odd, I guess, would be the word, covered in Oscar-nominated makeup and really wanting you to know how many acting choices he made during filming. (It hasn't helped him much. Hanks has received three Razzie nominations for worst acting this year, including for his performance in Elvis.) But the saving grace of Elvis is Austin Butler in the title role, just straddling the edge enough between originality and impersonation. At the end of the day, the film is yet another example of a movie that was way less interesting than its trailer.

47. Empire of Light
Cinematography (Roger Deakins)

Predictably, Empire of Light—taking place mostly in a lavish but deteriorating cinema in the early 1980—is a gorgeous one to look at, with a color palate by Roger Deakins many will recognize from a lot of the films he' shot, but the film's story leaves much to be desired. It has a few big names (Olivia Coleman, Colin Firth) and a big director (Sam Mendes, who also wrote the screenplay), but it's unfortunately a bit of a bore, with overly showy performances and not much else. What exactly is the point of this movie? For the guy who gave us Road to Perdition, Skyfall, and 1917, it's fair to say that Empire of Light doesn't come close to matching his previous work.

46. The Whale
Actor in a Leading Role (Brendan Fraser), Actress in a Supporting Role (Hong Chao), Makeup and Hairstyling (Adrien Morot, Judy Chin, and Annemarie Bradley)

For those who think A24 can do no wrong, they may want to consider viewing The Whale. Surely, even those who haven't seen it have at least heard of it, mainly because Brendan Fraser, ever since he received a standing ovation at the Venice Film Festival last September, has been all over the place promoting it. In The Whale, Fraser plays Charlie, a reclusive, self-loathing, six-hundred-pound man apparently eating himself to death and desperate to find redemption from his daughter, whom he abandoned years ago. You've likely also heard of the controversy regarding the film, namely the sort of pseudo-empathetic nature of this story directed by Darren Aronofsky and written by Samuel D. Hunter, who adapted it from his 2012 play, and the fat suit. Beyond that, Sadie Sink's performance as Charlie's psychotic daughter is basically the same note throughout the film's entirety. A consensus, however, is that Hong Chao as Charlie's nurse friend who cares for him is great; so, too, is Samantha Morton as his ex-wife. The Whale, which I suppose has its heart in the right place, left me feeling kind of dumbfounded, and I'd like to end by quoting Glenn Weldon's criticism of it all: "It's just a thread of self-righteousness, or a kind of delusional nobility, a kind of sense of, you're welcome." 

45. Night Ride 
Live Action Short Film (Eirik Tveiten and Gaute Lid Larssen)

Night Ride, the Norwegian short film directed by Eirik Tveiten, is a film that also has its heart in the right place. Tveiten told the New Yorker (whose YouTube channel you can view it) that the story is about everyone's responsibility to help those who are being harassed. Those are noble intentions, indeed, but the end result is one that left me feeling uneasy at times. Even if it didn't, the whole thing starts off so nonsensically, as a woman is too cold to wait for a tram that will park for half an hour, so she decides to steal it. If the whole film is about standing up to tormentors against vulnerable people, why start off that way? One thing I really enjoyed about the film, however, is Sigrid Kandal Husjord's performance as Ebba, the main character. 

44. Women Talking
Original Screenplay (Sarah Polley), Best Picture (Dede Gardner, Jeremy Kleiner, and Frances McDormand)

Women Talking is quite...talkative. Your mileage for non-stop dialogue will really help determine how much you like or don't like a film like this. Adapted for the screen by Sarah Polly from a 2018 novel by Miriam Toews about women in a Mennonite community debating whether or not to leave their homes after being brutally sedated and raped by men in their community (I really wish that no such event served as the inspiration for such a novel and film, but I regret to say that such a thing did happen), its strengths lie in the acting of its cast. Many have lauded its bigger stars like Rooney Mara and Claire Foy, but I would like to praise Judith Ivey and Sheila McCarthy as the community elders. Despite the commendable acting, the film can be quite boring.  

43. Living
Actor in a Leading Role (Bill Nighy), Adapted Screenplay (Kazuo Ishiguro)

Living is an unlikely film. It is a British remake of a somewhat famous 1952 Japanese film called Ikiru ("to live" in English), which was inspired by Leo Tolstoy's 1886 novella The Death of Ivan Ilyich. The story is about a dying bureaucrat (played here by Bill Nighy) who suddenly decides to devote his final days to actually improve the lives of regular people. But much like the original film, in my humble opinion, Living is dreadfully boring and overrated. True, there are a few moving moments when the protagonist decides to positively use what remaining time he has left, and Nighy, who's made a career of playing affable, larger-than-life characters, certainly gives us a different type of performance than we're used to seeing from him. But the non-stop whispering tone of his character only makes the film feel even more never ending. 

42. How Do You Measure a Year?
Documentary Short Film (Jay Rosenblatt)

The documentary short How Do You Measure a Year?, directed by Jay Rosenblatt (who was also nominated in this same category last year for his experiences bullying a classmate in When We Were Bullies), is a film in which he has edited together footage of his annual interviews of his daughter, Ella, one her birthday from the age of two to eighteen. Ella is quite candid, though sometimes predictably bored (when she's an infant) and reserved (when she's a teenager), and she discusses some of the highs and lows in their father-daughter relationship. This whole experience surely makes for a therapeutic experience for the both of them. For the average viewer, though, I'm not sure it's worth the thirty-minute time investment.  

41. The Sea Beast
Animated Feature Film (Chris Williams and Jed Schlanger)

Look, I totally understand why many animators are furious at how the Academy sees them. I get it. But I have to sum up The Sea Beast by calling it not necessarily a cute film but one that will likely be enjoyed a lot more by its young viewers than their parents. What parents will like are things like the voice cast (namely Karl Urban and Jared Harris), who are mostly fine. But they may also shrug at some of the usual beats that are there: messages about how humans and not beasts of the sea are (or often are) the real enemies, we all have to respect nature, and things like that. However, The Seat Beast is undeniably one of the most forgettable of all the nominees this year, and it's in large part to the fact that the sea beasts aren't remotely interesting. Why not embrace some realism? Greenland sharks are estimated to live as long as 250-500 years, so why not have have one of them be the sea beast at the heart of this film and not that awkward red thing?

40. The Ice Merchants
Animated Short Film (JoĂŁo Gonzalez and Bruno Caetano)

Each year, the Oscar-nominated animated shorts tend to have the most wonderful otherworldly animation, and The Ice Merchants, directed by Portuguese director JoĂŁo Gonzalez (his third film), is no different. The dialogue-less film, about a father and son who parachute into town in order to sell ice, took Gonzalez about two years to make after starting it as a student project. Since then, the film has been on a roll, winning forty-four prizes at over one hundred festivals, including the Leitz Cine Discovery Prize for short film. Should it win the big one? Well, it's not my favorite of the five nominees. For one, the film is a bit impenetrable in its first half, with the unique animation not doing enough to make up for its flaws. Fortunately, the film, as its stakes rise during its climactic scene, eventually becomes more engaging.   

39. An Ostrich Told Me the World Is Fake and I Think I Believe It
Animated Short Film (Lachlan Pendragon)

For its clever concept and painstaking stop motion animation, student filmmaker Lachlan Pendragon (who also voices the main character) certainly deserves a nomination for this postmodernist tale of a bored office worker who is told by an ostrich that (you guessed it) the world is fake, and he starts to believe it. Why? The real-world dimensions of animation manifest in front of his eyes: he can see the green screen, his face starts to fall off, and there's even a human hand chasing. The film's humor, which seems influenced by that of Taika Waititi (there's even an officemate of the protagonist who sounds like him) is copiously used here, and while it might not actually ever provoke laughter, it's humorous enough.

38. Ivalu
Live Action Short Film (Anders Walter and Rebecaa Pruzan)

Given the shockingly high rate of violence against young people in Greenland, it is understandable that Ivalu, about a missing indigenous girl, would be a harrowing subject. Sometimes the film is better when it allows the viewer to theorize about what has happened. At any rate, Ivalu proves yet again that it often is better to hire untrained actors for an experience of verisimilitude, as actor Mila Heilmann Kreutzmann as the protagonist really helps elevate the film.   

37. An Irish Goodbye
Live Action Short Film (Tom Berkeley and Ross White)

An Irish Goodbye is a poignant black comedy about two brothers who reunite in rural Northern Ireland after their mother's death. The two start to quarrel. Turlough (Seamus O'Hara) lives in London, while his brother, Lorcan (James Martin), wishes to remain on the family farm, but Turlough insists that he goes to live with their aunt. (Lorcan has Down syndrome.) They attempt to heal their bitterness with a bucket list, seemingly from their deceased mother. If films in this category are not playing on Netflix or YouTube, the winner of the five nominees are usually difficult to predict. Even though it was not my favorite of the five films nominated, it does seem that An Irish Goodbye, fresh off its BAFTA win last month, is the frontrunner, with Next Best Picture and Slant both predicting a win. The only one that could realistically stop it is...

36. Le pupille 
Live Action Short Film (Alice Rohrwacher and Alfonso CuarĂłn)

For much of this nearly forty-minute Italian film shot in Super 16 and 35 mm format about a group of girls at a Catholic orphanage celebrating Christmas, I was not sure if I liked it or not. I admire the film's resemblance to works like the 1993 adaption of A Little Princess (directed by Alfonso CuarĂłn, a producer of the film, who would nab his sixth win with eleven nominations if Le pupille wins), but the film's suggestions of a link between Mussolini's fascist Italy and Pius XII's Catholic Church are as wearisome as they were in Guillermo Del Toro's Pinocchio, with both films feeling like they are either clichĂ©s or missed opportunities. And the film's chortle about lacking a moral at the end is either a plus or minus, depending on your perspective. Still, it more or less is an engaging, lighthearted, somewhat nostalgic film that some might revisit often at Christmastime.  

35. To Leslie
Actress in a Leading Role (Andrea Riseborough) 

By now, everyone knows that one of the biggest surprises of these nominations was Andrea Riseborough's nominated performance as Leslie, an addict trying to rebuild her life after losing all her money and being ostracized by her family and community. I had seen the film late last year because I always try to see as many of the top 100 films of the year according to Rotten Tomatoes. (For 2022, To Leslie is currently ranked near the top at number eight.) Part of the surprise is that To Leslie is a pretty mediocre film, and Riseborough's performance, while not bad, isn't all that unforgettable, either. As you can imagine, there is a lot of screaming and crying and that sort of thing; it's very over the top in an Oscar-bait way, but the film did have many powerful friends. What may have added to everyone's shock and anger is that Riseborough's nomination helped keep Danielle Deadwyler of Till and Octavia Spencer of The Woman King off, adding fuel to the fire of arguments that the Academy doesn't like to nominate Black women, and the subsequent investigation at the board meeting only made things more uncomfortable.    

34. The Flying Sailor
Animated Short Film (Amanda Forbis and Wendy Tilby)

The Flying Sailor, the third Oscar nomination for Canadian animation duo Amanda Forbis and Wendy Tilby, is an animated short film inspired by a sailor's real-life experience during the 1917 Halifax Explosion that killed almost two thousand people. It shows us the sailor (naked for most of the film) going through a a nearly eight-minute somersault through the air (perhaps into another dimension or form of life) while his life flashes before his eyes. The filmmakers used accounts of trauma and near-death experiences to help visualize this sailor's surreal voyage. It's a fascinating interpretation of this actual tragedy, and it's animated creatively, though it is also one of the more forgettable films on this list.

33. Mrs. Harris Goes to Paris
Costume Design (Jenny Beaven)

The third adaptation of the novel Mrs. 'Arris Goes to Paris, this film might charm the socks off many due to its delightful acting from its star Lesley Manville and the Paris scenery, but it also has more than one moment that will likely make you roll your eyes, and the movie can be so bland that you might forget you watched it the very next day. (Beyond that, the better of these types of sugary English movies from last year was The Duke, with Jim Broadbent and Helen Mirren.) Still, it's anti-snobbery, pro-kindness attitude is a pleasant one. Mrs. Harris Goes to Paris is a love letter to dresses and the making of them, so Jenny Beaven, who (in addition to winning for A Room With A View and Mad Max: Fury Road), also won last year for Cruella), stands a good chance at winning for all those beautiful dresses. 

32. Turning Red
Animated Feature Film (Domee Shi and Lindsey Collins)

Pixar films—at least the best of them—will stay with you after just one viewing. I watched this film on Disney+ early last year (or was it in the summer?), and I confess to not remembering much about it. It doesn't really matter if I wasn't over the moon or not regarding Turning Red. Some of the criticism of the film was abnormally bone-headed, but many have noted the success Billie Eilish and Finneas O'Connell at channeling the mood of early aughts pop music. 

31. Aftersun
Actor in a Leading Role (Paul Mescal)

About an eleven-year-old girl on a vacation at a Turkish resort with her father (who is going through a bit of a midlife—or quarter-life—crisis), Aftersun successfully secured a Best Actor nomination for its lead star, Paul Mescsal, as the father. Mescal's performance is good and all, but the more impressive performance is that of Frankie Corio as Sophie, the young girl. The film has been a hit with the critics, ranking at number one in the Sight and Sound top-fifty list (I don't really care; their lists often come across as self-righteous and pretentious), but the first two-thirds of it are just the father and daughter on vacation trying to find ways to occupy their time. Much of the rest of the film has moments that I suppose are up to the audience to interpret, but this often comes across as gimmicky. Look, it's a good movie with two really strong performances, but even though it's only an hour and a half, it sometimes feels like it will never end.  

30. Guillermo Del Toro's Pinocchio 
Animated Feature Film (Guillermo Del Toro, Mark Gustafson, Gary Ungar, and Alex Bulkey)

I'm going to go ahead and trust Honest Trailers that Guillermo Del Toro's Pinocchio, the seventy-sixth adaptation of this famous tale in the past three years, is the best (or least bad) of the three versions from last year. The animation is great, no doubt, and it will likely win in this category. (Should Guillermo Del Toro win here, it would be his third Oscar. He also won in 2018 for producing and directing The Shape of Water.) There are some somewhat interesting attempts to update the story for a more modern audience, this time by adding villainous components of fascism and authoritarianism, favorite targets of Del Toro's. But this Pinocchio adaptation undeniably grows less interesting as it inches its way to the conclusion, and those songs are almost comically forgettable. Also, Finn Wolfhard's fake (English?) accent is very distracting.

29. My Year of Dicks
Animated Short Film (Sara GunnarsdĂłttir and Pamela Ribon)

You have to give the Academy of Motion Picture Arts and Sciences credit for nominating a film titled My Year of Dicks. (I initially predicted the film's title, which provoked a series of giggles when Riz Ahmed announced it as a nominee on January 24, was a double entendre, and it is, but it's not the one I was expecting.) With rotoscope animation and narrative style that may remind many of the work of Richard Linklater, the cleverly titled coming-of-age animated flick written by Pamela Ribon and directed by Sara GunnarsdĂłttir about a teenage girl in Houston's journey to lose her virginity while navigating a sea of disappointing experiences starts a bit shaky but eventually becomes simultaneously intense, chaotic, funny, relatable, and nostalgic. 

28. Stranger at the Gate
Documentary Short Film (Joshua Seftel and Conall Jones)

It's probably best if you know as little about Stranger at the Gate as possible going in to see it, especially because where it ends up is probably not where most would expect it to. Therefore, it's difficult to fill up some sentences about a short documentary in which I'd rather not describe the story. Ultimately, though, I can say that this film is a reminder of all the good that can come out of peace, acceptance, and empathy. With that being said, despite its intriguing story, it is perhaps the least memorable of the five documentary shorts nominated this year. 

27. Top Gun: Maverick 
Film Editing (Eddie Hamilton), Original Song ("Hold My Hand" by Lady Gaga and BloodPop), Sound (Mark Weingarten, James H. Mather, Al Nelson, Chris Burdon, Mark Taylor), Visual Effects (Ryan Tudhope, Seth Hill, Bryan Litson, and Scott R. Fisher), Adapted Screenplay (Ehren Kruger, Eric Warren Singer, Christopher McQuarrie, Peter Craig, and Justin Marks), Best Picture (Tom Cruise, Christopher McQuarrie, David Ellison, and Jerry Bruckheimer)

I am very happy that so many people took such great joy in a movie (the one that I think most people were expecting to flop but turned into the one that saved Hollywood). It's just that I couldn't help but being marveled at the thrills of the film while simultaneously feeling underwhelmed by it holistically. The screenplay, which is nominated, is at times laughable, like when Tom Cruise frequently tells his protĂ©gĂ© to "do, don't think." But in the script's defense, it later humorously mocks itself in the film's best scene when that logic falls flat on its face as Cruise and Miles Teller shout at each other in the snowy forest. Still, it's remarkable that they made a sequel to an 80s action flick basically no one was asking for anymore and few, I think, had high expectations that turned into a mega blockbuster and one of the most talked-about films of the year. The action sequences involving the jets are unlike anything any of us have ever seen on screen, and the Lady Gaga song is great. 

26. The Batman
Makeup and Hairstyling (Naomi Donne, Mike Marino, and Mike Fontaine), Sound (Stuart Wilson, William Files, Douglas Murray, and Andy Nelson), Visual Effects (Dan Lemmon, Russell Earl, Anders Langlands, and Dominic Tuohy)

The Batman tries really, really hard to outdo The Dark Knight. Writer and director Matt Reeves apparently even boasted to Christopher Nolan that that was his goal. Achieve it, he did not. The Batman works on some levels: The score by Michael Giacchino is memorable (yet a bit repetitive), though certainly not to the same level as Danny Elfman's or Hans Zimmer's from previous installments. The makeup effects are stupendous. And the good-cop-bad-cop detective story routine of Robert Pattinson's Batman and Jeffrey Wright's James Gorden is commendable. The performances in general, though, are a bit all over the place, with Colin Farrell as Penguin shining but Paul Dano as the Riddler giving us his most ridiculous performance ever. But much like Joker three years before it, The Batman (unlike most other Caped Crusader adventures) is completely devoid of any element of fun, and it increasingly is a big ask for its audience to tolerate its runtime. 

25. Avatar: The Way of Water
Production Design (Dylan Cole, Ben Procter, Vanessa Cole), Sound (Julian Howarth, Gwendolyn Yates Whittle, Dick Bernstein, Christopher Boyes, Gary Summers, and Michael Hedges), Visual Effects (Joe Letteri, Richard Baneham, Eric Saindon, and Daniel Barrett), Best Picture (James Cameron and Jon Landau)

Thirteen years after the James Cameron-directed mega-blockbuster Avatar was released, we finally got our sequel (the first of four, apparently). What works with this follow-up, showcasing the Navi couple played by Sam Worthington and Zoe Saldaña and their four kids (one of whom is a teenager played very distractingly by Sigourney Weaver), is what worked in the first one: its universal themes and anti-colonial message, as well as its stunning visuals, especially the water-based ones. Some of Cameron's most fascinating works (like The Abyss and Titanic) have been about the sea, and this is no different. The film richly deserves to win in the visual effects category. What doesn't work in Avatar: The Way of Water is what also didn't particularly work in the first one: things like narrative and how patronizing the analogies to indigenous culture can feel. And at the end of the 192 minutes, I asked myself if I really had it in the tank to watch three more of these. 

24. Black Panther: Wakanda Forever
Actress in a Supporting Role (Angela Bassett), Costume Design (Ruth Carter), Makeup and Hairstyling (Camille Friend and Joel Harlow), Original Song ("Lift Me Up" by Tems, Rihanna, Ryan Coogler, Ludwig Goransson), Visual Effects (Geoffrey Baumann, Craig Hammack, R. Christopher White, and Dan Sudick)

Black Panther: Wakanda Forever places considerable emphasis on mourning and grief given the tragic passing of Chadwick Boseman in 2020. This is a strength of the film, as is its acting (for the most part), mainly Letitia Wright, who takes over the lead role; Dominique Thorne as a new character, a brilliant scientist; Tenoch Huerta as Namor, the anti-hero mutant leading a sea-based people against Wakanda; and Angela Bassett returning as Queen Rasmonda, who could win this year for Supporting Actress. (A lot of attention was made to Viola Davis and Danielle Deadwyler not being nominated, but one could also make a very strong case that Wright should have garnered more attention for her acting here.) The weak parts of the film are its unjustifiably long length, the unnecessary subplot involving characters played by Martin Freeman and Julia Louis-Dreyfus, and many of the action scenes, which are often the worst parts of Marvel movies. 

23. The Boy, the Mole, the Fox and the Horse
Short Animated Film (Charlie Mackesy and Matthrew Freud)

There are a lot of platitudes about perseverance, kindness, "home is where the heart is," and that sort of stuff in this gorgeous adaptation of Charlie Mackesy's illustrated book about a blossoming friendship between a boy (Jude Coward Nicoll), a mole (Tom Hollander), a fox (Indris Elba), and a horse (Gabriel Byrne). But it's still a neat film. The animation, wonderfully hand-drawn remotely by 120 people in 20 countries during the COVID-19 pandemic, is gorgeous, and because it's an Apple TV+ film, given their enormous success last year with CODA winning three Oscars (including Best Picture), I'd say that helps make The Boy, the Mole, the Fox and the Horse the frontrunner here. It's a great film to look at, but other than its didactic qualities for younger audience members, it's unlikely to stay very long in adults' memories.

22. Argentina, 1985
International Feature Film (Argentina)

Of the five nominees for International Feature Film, Argentina, 1985, about the trials of military leaders of the dictatorship, is the most conventional; that's either a plus or a minus, depending on your perspective. One way or the other, there are two things that help the film shine: the film's occasional humor and the presence and performance of Ricardo DarĂ­n as the lead prosecutor. Other than that, Argentina, 1985 can unfortunately feel at times like, as Aisha Harris put it, a crowd-pleasing Hollywood-esque courtroom drama. How much of that you're into will vary from viewer to viewer. 

21. RRR
Original Song ("Naatu Naatu" by M.M. Keeravaani and Chandrabose)

RRR, the Indian epic action/musical flick, is sort of an on-one-hand-on-the-other-hand kind of film. On one hand, its action sequences, particularly in its first half, are thrilling. On the other hand, the film drags tremendously after the big palace attack, essentially feeling like one slow-motion sequence after the other, with CGI tigers aplenty. On one hand, its song "Naatu Naatu" (the frontrunner for Best Song) will long be remembered. On the other hand, none of the other songs will be. On one hand, Ram Charan's acting, especially with all his singing, dancing, fighting, and just plain scowling, are impeccable. On the other hand, most of the other acting (especially all the British actors and their mustache twirling) might cause you to roll your eyes. To sum up, I think if RRR were ninety minutes instead of one hundred and eighty, thereby possibly allowing it to eliminate or at least minimize the aspects I didn't care for, I would've liked it a lot more. 

20. Glass Onion (I refuse to call it Glass Onion: A Knives Out Story because that is a stupid title.) 
Adapted Screenplay (Rian Johnson)

Minor spoilers below.

It was inevitable that Rian Johnson's follow-up to Knives Out, which also earned him an Oscar nomination, would be at least somewhat less interesting than the first. That is certainly the case here (and every other sequel nominated this year), though most viewers seem to love both films in equal amounts. In many respects, I don't blame them. Yes, I found myself considerably less interested in Glass Onion than in Knives Out, especially when it swerves in a completely different direction towards the end of the second act and suddenly becomes a lot talkier. That being said, it's still a murder mystery, which are usually neat, aren't they? The actors, especially Daniel Craig as Benoit Blanc and Edward Norton as the Elon Musk-esque douche of the story, all appear to be having a blast. That being said, Janelle Monáe, despite how perfect she is, gives a Southern accent that's a bit too off (to say nothing of Craig's fake drawl, which is becoming tiring), and most of those cameos are just distracting and unnecessary. But the film does get bonus points for providing a surprising and fitting final screen appearance of the late, great Angela Lansbury.

19. The Fabelmans
Actor in a Supporting Role (Judd Hirsch), Actress in a Leading Role (Michelle Williams), Directing (Steven Spielberg), Original Score (John Williams), Production Design (Rick Carter and Karen O'Hara), Original Screenplay (Steven Spielberg and Tony Kushner), Best Picture (Kristie Macosko Krieger, Steven Spielberg, and Tony Kushner)

I suppose if you're the single most successful director in Hollywood history, you're allowed to make a biographical film after half a century in the profession. I guess you're also allowed to let that film go on, and on...and on, which is what The Fabelmans, Steven Spielberg's semi-autobiographical film that's a love letter to his coming-of-age experiences, his family, and his craft, unfortunately does. Spielberg partisans will certainly be delighted, though, for everything you've come to expect in films he directs—the expression of wonder, the potent lights, fights with fathers (and in this case, mothers)—and every anecdote we've heard from the master himself over the years, such as seeing The Greatest Show on Earth as a boy, making movies with his sisters or fellow Boy Scouts as actors, going through his parents' divorce, and being the target of anti-Semitic bullying, is all there. What's missing is much of the awe that has been so prevalent in many of his previous films; even his recent remake of West Side Story felt fresher. But what does really assist The Fabelmans is its superb acting, especially Gabrielle LaBelle and Mateo Zoryan Francis-DeFord as younger versions of the Spielberg character (named Sam). This year's Oscar race for leading actress is a horse race between Michelle Yeoh and Cate Blanchett, but Michelle Williams as the mother shouldn't be counted out. One more thing: My earliest memory of going to the movies was when I was six, and like little Sammy in this film, my mother mentioned to me before we got to the theater that I shouldn't be too afraid when watching the film. The movie we were seeing: Jurassic Park, directed by Steven Spielberg.

18. All the Beauty and the Bloodshed
Documentary Feature Film (Laura Poitras, Howard Gertler, John Lyons, Nan Goldin, and Yoni Golijov)

All the Beauty and the Bloodshed is a documentary about the artist Nan Goldin, and it focuses almost equally on her formative years developing as an artist (including facts about herself she had never shared before) and her more recent years channeling her rage as an opioid survivor going after the powerful Sackler family, owners of Purdue Pharma. Both halves of the documentary are about equally interesting, though I suppose I leaned more towards the latter due to its timeliness and wanted to see more of that. Longtime fans of Goldin's, however, may likely feel the opposite. 

17. All That Breathes
Documentary Feature Film (Shaunak Sen, Aman Mann, and Teddy Leifer)

All That Breathes is one of many environmental films that could likely leave you feeling gutted by the end. Centering on two brothers who run a bird clinic as a side gig in New Delhi, it's a beautiful yet sad documentary. The brothers are in dire need, as black kites, a gorgeous bird that serves an important ecological purpose but one that is apparently thought of as a nuisance, are increasingly falling from the sky due to the intensive pollution of the city. This pollution and the backdrop of violent Hindu nationalism that could threaten the safety of these two men and their families (the brothers are Muslim) serve as impeding dread over the film.  

16. The Quiet Girl
International Feature Film (Ireland)

The Quiet Girl has been on a mighty run since it debuted in Berlin last year. The debut of writer-director Colm BairĂ©ad, it has gone on to become the highest-grossing Irish-language film of all time, as as well as the first Irish film to be nominated for Best International Feature Film. It is also ranked number six on Rotten Tomatoes and number ten on Meta Critic for the top one-hundred films of 2022. The beginning part of The Quiet Girl, about a young, shy girl being sent away to a farm for the summer in 1981 to spend time with distance relatives, may take the patience of a saint, so it might turn off some viewers. However, it's worth the wait, especially to see the acting of the three main performers: Catherine Clinch as the main character, Carrie Crowley as her first cousin once removed, and Andrew Bennett as the husband farmer.  

15. The Martha Mitchell Effect
Documentary Short Film (Anne Alvergue and Beth Levison)

Towards the end of the short (sometimes generic) documentary The Martha Mitchell Effect, we hear an archival interview in which Barbara Walters asks Martha Mitchell, the gregarious, genial, potent, and powerful wife of Richard Nixon's Attorney General and campaign manager, how she would like be be remembered in the history books. Mitchell's answers is that she wants to be thought of as someone who served her country. That she is now in part thanks to this Netflix documentary. Like Cassandra long before her, Mitchell's warnings about Nixon and Watergate were dismissed as being symptoms of a supposed mental illness, which is how the term "Martha Mitchell effect" eventually came into being. I confess that while many older viewers may have memories (some fond and some not so fond) of Mitchell's time in Washington, I had never heard of her. (Maybe I should have; Julia Roberts started playing her on Gaslit last year.) Therefore, I'm very happy I got to see this documentary and learn about her. 

14. Triangle of Sadness
Best Picture (Erik Hemmendorff and Philippe Bober), Directing (Ruben Ă–stlund), Original Screenplay (Ruben Ă–stlund)

I've always had zero interest in taking a cruise, and that lack of desire was only augmented after viewing the Palme d'Or-winning satirical, eat-the-rich black comedy Triangle of Sadness, written and directed by Ruben Ă–stlund, whose films often are the darlings of the Cannes Film Festival. The film follows a young couple going through ups and downs in three parts, but it's the disastrous cruise for the super-wealthy in the middle of the movie that feature the best moments. With an ensemble cast that includes Harris Dickinson and Charli Dean (who tragically died before the film was released) as the couple, as well as Dolly de Leon, Zlatko Burić, Henrik Dorson, Vicki Berlin, and Woody Harrleson, Ă–stlund's sharp script contains more mature anti-colonial themes than Black Panther: Wakanda Forever and Avatar: Way of the Water did, but other than the film's runtime, the only other major complaint I have about it is that if your appetite drives you towards this kind of anti-rich black comedy, you're bound to get better quality with HBO's The White Lotus television series. 

13. Fire of Love
Documentary Feature Film (Sara Dosa, Shane Boris, and Ina Fichman)

Fire of Love may remind many of recent documentaries that championed lovers of nature, like Playing with Sharks about Valerie Taylor and Becoming Cousteau about Jacques Cousteau. It may also remind some of documentaries that depicted people doing remarkably brave things that many of us would find irresponsible and stupidly dangerous, such as Grizzly Man, about a man living among wild grizzly bears, and the Oscar-winning Free Solo, about a free solo climber. Fire of Love, directed, written, produced, and narrated by Sara Dosa, is a marriage of the two kinds. The film centers on archival footage of French volcanologists Katia and Maurice Krafft, who appeared to love volcanos (and the thrill of being near them) just as much as they did each other. Despite all the constant beauty of the frequent lava we witness in this archival footage, as well as the internal debates we may or may not be having about the risks of such work, the film is unlikely to stay with viewers (or at least with me) as the other two documentaries I haven't yet discussed.  

12. A House Made of Splinters
Documentary Feature Film (Simon Lereng Wilmont and Monica Hellström)

Going into A House Made of Splinters, the only thing I knew about it was that it was about Ukraine. Viewing it two days before the one-year anniversary of Russia's invasion, I assumed it would be a film about the tragic war. Yet this film does not center on the conflict, though it exists in its shadows. Instead, A House Made of Splinters, an international co-production with Denmark, Ukraine, Sweden, and Finland, focuses on the experiences of several children in an institution twenty-five kilometers from the frontline run by a few women. The institution houses children whose parents are struggling with alcoholism. Of the four children we see the most, the saddest scenes involve a teenage boy named Kolya, who, though he often gets in trouble with the police, is devotedly helping to raise his siblings in the absence of their mother, whom we only see in one moment as she tearfully embraces him and pleads with him to take better care of himself. It's a remarkable film, but be warned: For those who feel sorrowful from the frequent bad news coming from war in Ukraine, it might be best to avoid A House Made of Splinters.  

11. Navalny
Documentary Feature Film (Daniel Roher, Odessa Rae, Diane Becker, Melanie Miller, and Shane Boris)

Exciting hardly seems like the most appropriate word for a documentary about the attempted assassination and imprisonment of an opposition figure by the vampiric thug that is Vladimir Vladimirovich Putin, but there are a variety of scenes in Navalny, about one of the thug's most notable critics, that will stay with you, especially by favorite: Navalny and his associates trapping one of his attempted assassins into admitting over the phone his crime. It's a scene that borders on the surreal and absurd to the point where some (especially pro-Putin critics of Navalny) may shout to the heavens that the whole thing was staged. Critics of the documentary might say the film borders on hero worshipping, especially as it only briefly sails through Navalny's previous controversial alliances with members of the far right in Russia. In terms of predicting the winner in this category, my hunch is that Navalny will win, in part because it's the best and in part because voters may be aching to publicly rebuke Vladimir Putin.  

10. EO
International Feature Film (Poland)

Like the documentary Cow from last year, EO, a Polish film inspired by the 1966 French film Au Hasard Balthazar about a donkey's trials and tribulations as it passes from human ownership to human ownership, is a potent reminder of the cruelty human beings place on other species. Thus, animal lovers may understandably find some of these scenes too difficult to watch. Personally, I was mesmerized by just about every scene featuring the title character, and my heart ached as I watched him (or her?) appear helpless, confused, and lost. Viewers may also feel helpless, confused, and lost as they watch this movie, as so many of the human characters deliberately come in and out of the story without much explanation (we often don't see how EO comes under the supervision of a new person); some of these situations work, while some (like Isabelle Huppert's peculiar scenes in which she shows up and starts breaking dishes) don't. The camera tricks, like the powerful red hue that appears once and a while, also feel showy at times. But if one can forgive these flaws, one will be moved (and horrified) by EO.   

9. All Quiet on the Western Front
Cinematography (James Friend), International Feature Film (Germany), Makeup and Hairstyling (Heike Merker and Linda Eisenhamerová), Original Score (Volker Bertelmann), Production Design (Christian M. Goldbeck and Ernestein Hipper), Sound (Viktor Prášil, Frank Kruse, Markus Stemler, Lars Ginzel, and Stefan Korte), Visual Effects (Frank Petzold, Viktor Müller, Markus Frank, and Kamil Jafar), Adapted Screenplay (Edward Berger, Lesley Paterson, and Ian Stokell), Best Picture (Malte Grunert)

The second big-screen adaptation of Erich Marie Remarque's anti-war novel (which was eventually banned and burned by the Nazis) about the disillusionment and alienation Germany's Lost Generation suffered through during World War I, this one is surely better than the 1930 version, which took me several sittings to make it through. That version won Best Picture way back in the day, and while this version is unlikely to match such a feat, it still stands a chance of bagging at least a few Oscars. The sheer scope of this massive film, from its enormous production design to its potent score to its horrifying yet realistic makeup, are quite impressive, as are the powerful reminders of the horrors of war. The only major critique I have of the film is how derivative it sometimes feels; indeed, after a production like 1917 or even War Horse (both superior films set during World War I), it sort of is a wonder as to why they even bothered making a new All Quiet on the Western Front.    

8. Everything Everywhere All at Once
Actor in a Supporting Role (Ke Huy Quan), Actress in a Lead Role (Michelle Yeoh), Actress in a Supporting Role (Jamie Lee Curtis), Actress in a Supporting Role (Stephanie Hsu), Costume Design (Shirley Kurata), Film Editing (Paul Rogers), Original Score (Son Lux), Original Song ("This Is a Life" by Ryan Lott, David Byrne, and Mitski), Original Screenplay (Daniel Kwan and Daniel Scheinert), Best Picture (Daniel Kwan, Daniel Scheinert, and Jonathan Wang)

Everything Everywhere All at Once is the movie I'm rooting for. I want it to win Best Picture. I want Michelle Yeoh and Ke Huy Quan (and maybe Jamie Lee Curtis) to win for their acting. David Byrne already has an Oscar (for co-writing the score for The Last Emperor), but how cool would it be if he won again? I want this film to sweep the Oscars. A science fiction comedy about a middle-aged Asian mom fighting her way through a multiverse should win the top prizes! And yet, I was a lot more underwhelmed by this hit than everyone else once was. To be clear, I find its premise rousing and the first half particularly enticing. But then the movie's schtick gets old. It becomes overly quirky, in my opinion. It's weird for the sake of being weird. I can remember quite a bit about that first half; I remember almost nothing from its second. For a variety of reasons, Everything Everywhere All at Once deserves to win in most of the categories its nominated in; that doesn't mean I'm in love with it.

7. Causeway
Actor in a Supporting Role (Brian Tyree Henry)

In Causeway, Jennifer Lawrence (a producer of the film) plays a veteran who was wounded in Afghanistan and is struggling to adjust back to life in New Orleans. While adjusting, she develops a friendship with a mechanic played by Brian Tyree Henry, who is nominated for Best Supporting Actor. One could certainly make an argument for Henry winning the Oscar for his work here. Like many of the films nominated this year, the story may not stick with you, but the acting will. Along with Lawrence and Henry, other commendable performances are by Linda Emond, Jayne Houdyshell, and Stephen McKinley Henderson. Lawerence is just as great as she always is in this low-key but multi-faceted performance, but I came away thinking a lot more about Henry, and I'm greatly looking forward to his future projects.

6. Haulout
Documentary Short Film (Evgenia Arbugaeva and Maxim Arbugaev)

Haulout focuses on a marine biologist in arctic Serbia observing a walrus haulout. We first see these walruses the first morning he sees them (presumably), and the images and sounds feel like those seen and heard in otherworldly works of science fiction. These scenes are totally mesmerizing, but something is off. For starters, one wonders why the walruses are there, and why their numbers are so large. Soon, the culprit becomes clear: global warming. The walruses (at a peak of 100,000) are hauling out on the coast due to more limited ice, which they have always relied on for rest. The consequences are dispiriting. Both Evgenia Arbugaeva and Maxim Arbugaev were born in the Russian arctic and are now based elsewhere (Arbugaeva in London and Arbugaev in Moscow), and yet the viewer can sense how important this story is to them. Fifteen years after the Oscar-winning climate change documentary An Inconvenient Truth left viewers shocked and yet filled with hope that something could be done before it was too late, Haulout features no such optimism or call to action, only the facts and a marine biologist's melancholy.   

5. The Elephant Whisperers
Documentary Short Film (Kartiki Gonsalves and Guneet Monga)

Given the fact that everyone loves elephants, especially baby elephants, I think most viewers would be quite enamored with The Elephant Whisperers. About a couple raising two orphaned elephants in the Mudumalai National Park in India, this tender documentary is a great watch. Just about every frame of the film features elephants, and yet this is one of the most humanist motion pictures nominated. So much of it acutely focuses on much of the human condition: life, love, death, learning, and (like Haulout, EO, and All That Breathes) the consequences we are placing on this planet for other species. The elephants do a lot of the heavy lifting (again, almost everyone loves elephants), but director Kartiki Gonsalves deserves a lot of the credit for crafting such a moving documentary about this couple and their work. It's my favorite of the five nominees in this category. 

4. The Banshees of Inisherin
Actor in a Leading Role (Colin Farrell), Actor in a Supporting Role (Brendan Gleeson), Actor in a Supporting Role (Barry Keoghan), Actress in a Supporting Role (Kerry Condon), Directing (Martin McDonagh), Film Editing (Mikkel E.G. Nielsen), Original Score (Carter Burwell), Original Screenplay (Martin McDonagh), Best Picture (Graham Broadbent, Pete Czernin, and Martin McDonagh)

I might be the only person on the planet who didn't like In Bruges, the last time Colin Farrell, Brendan Gleeson, and writer-director Martin McDonagh worked on a project together, so I was delighted that I (mostly) liked The Banshees of Inisherin, the tragicomedy about two friends in 1923 Ireland who suddenly aren't friends anymore and the violent repercussions of their split. This film, with its nihilistic tone and dialogue-heavy scenes, isn't for everyone, but even if people don't care for the story or the film's pace, they should be mightily in awe of its sharp, theatrical script and its performances, particularly the four Oscar nominees. And once you see the film, you'll forever wonder if each of your fingers are worth talking to really boring people. 

3. Close 
International Feature Film (Belgium)

Close is sort of a queer-adjacent film about two very close teenage boys named LĂ©o and RĂ©mi (played by Eden Dambrine and Gustav De Waele, respectively) whose friendship starts to unravel after some invasive questions by classmates who insist they're not being mean, which is followed by other teasing and then outright bullying. There is certainly a turning point in the film which potentially could alienate a chunk of its audience; Peter Debruge at Variety complained that the film is "so subtle and sensitive in the first half" before becoming "devastatingly false" and "incredibly, unwelcomely different." That may be a tad harsh, but I suspect it's how many will ultimately feel. Despite that, the acting is superb. Most of the films on this list featured phenomenal acting, but Close probably leads the pack, with Dambrine's being my favorite performance of all the films on this list.  

2. Tár
Actress in a Leading Role (Cate Blanchett), Cinematography (Florian Hoffmeister), Directing (Todd Field), Film Editing (Monika Willi), Original Screenplay (Todd Field), Best Picture (Todd Field, Alexandra Milchan, and Scott Lambert) 

Tár is only the third film Todd Fields has directed, and yet it's the work of a master. The film has so many things to say about debates over wokeness, cancel culture, power, and gender, and in weaker hands, things have become too convoluted and preachy. True, some have been turned off by what the film may or may not be saying on these issues (Richard Brody in the New Yorker called it "regressive"), and Cate Blanchett's performance as a (some might say monstrous) conductor may take a bit of getting used to, but it is an effective one, and other members of the cast deserve praise, as well: Nina Hoss as Sharon, a violinist and Lydia's wife; NoĂ©mie Merlant as Francesca, Lydia's assistant; Sophie Kauer as a cellist and Lydia's new favorite; Julian Glover as Andris, Lydia's mentor; Mila Bogojevic as Lydia and Sharon's daughter; and in only one (very memorable) scene, Zethphan Smith-Gneist as a student at Julliard Lydia tangles with. And unlike Everything Everywhere All at Once, which grows more taxing as it progresses, Tár gets better and better. Tár is not a perfect film (it wasn't even one of my favorites of last year), but it is one of the very best of all the nominees.

1. The Red Suitcase
Live Action Short Film (Cyrus Neshvad)

The Red Suitcase, directed by Cyrus Neshvad, is surely the best of the nominated live action short films and one of the best films I've seen in a while. The film is about a sixteen-year-old Iranian girl played by Nawelle Ewad who is sent to meet her middle-aged husband (Sawkaw Gorany) in an international airport in Luxembourg by her father. Scared and unable to communicate with anyone in French, English, or Luxembougish, she hides from the man she's been sold to and tries to escape the airport unnoticed. The film's cat-and-mouse nature sometimes endangers it by engaging in material beneath it, and if the filmmakers weren't careful, it probably would have gone there. But Neshad's direction and Ewad's acting are masterful, and it avoids such pratfalls. The film's championing of a scared teenage Iranian girl going against her conservative family's expectations of her makes this a very timely film, obviously, due to the recent revolt of Iranian women and their supporters, and (much like the Iranian government's brutal retaliation of protestors) the dichotomy between this girl and her "husband" is a painful one. The Red Suitcase is an eloquent reminder of the continuing struggles of women and girls in Iran for their rights, and I hope more people see it to be aware of their fight. I also hope it pulls an upset and wins the Oscar.